tiistai 8. toukokuuta 2018

Julkaistua 860: Niinistön muotokuva ei ole yhteisötaidetta


Tällainen ilmestyi eilen Helsingin Sanomien mielipidekirjoituksissa. Lillukanvarsista ei ole kyse. Pidän asiaa melko tärkeänä. Taiteesta puhuminen koetaan aivan liian joutavanpäiväisenä, ja mitä tahansa voi sanoa. Haluaisin enemmän tarkkuutta.
Itse juttua en nähnyt, koska se on maksumuurin takana, luen nykyään Hesarini baarissa. En siis tiedä, miten sitä on editoitu, mutta tässä alkuperäinen tekstini. Sen verran näin, että Teemu Luukan nimi oli poissa ja aloitus muutettu passiivisiksi. Miksiköhän?

Niinistön muotokuva ei ole yhteisötaidetta

Toisin kuin toimittaja Teemu Luukka kirjoittaa (Helsingin Sanomat 4.5.), presidentti Sauli Niinistön muotokuva ei ole yhteisötaidetta. Käsitteelle ’yhteisötaide’ (engl. community art) on ollut olemassa kohtuullisen vakiintunut käyttö jo 1960-luvulta, Suomessa ehkä 1990-luvulta. Kyse on taiteesta, jota tehdään jonkin yhteisön ehdoilla, yhteisön kanssa ja sitä varten. Usein kyse on yhteisöistä, joilla ei ole entuudestaan juurikaan taidesuhdetta. Taidetta voidaan käyttää esimerkiksi monin eri tavoin sosiaalisesti: koheesiota lisäämään, yhteisen tavoitteen apuneuvona, voimaannuttamiseen jne. Usein kyse on sosiaalisissa hierarkioissa alempana olevista yhteisöistä, joiden elämänlaatua pyritään parantamaan.


Sata satunnaisesti valittua taiteilijaa ei ole tässä mielessä aito yhteisö – niin paljon kuin taiteilijakuntamme elämänlaatua pitäisikin parantaa. 300 euroa / taiteilija ei tässäkään suhteessa ole kovin iso apu.
Tässä tapauksessa voisimme ehkä puhua ’yhteisteoksesta’. Oleellista olisi kuitenkin uutisoinnissa käyttää asianmukaista kieltä, jotta edes ymmärtäisimme toisiamme silloin, kun keskustelu kuohuu. Aivan vastaavasti muotokuva ei mielekkäästi voisi olla ’ympäristötaidetta’, vaikka presidentin esittelysali toki on jonkinlainen ympäristö.
On kuin taiteella ei olisi niin väliä. Muilla elämänalueilla tämä tuntuu olevan paljon selkeämpää. Taloustoimittaja ei koskaan kutsuisi ’veronkantoa’ ’joukkorahoitukseksi’ – vaikka joukollahan niitä veroja maksetaan.

106 kommenttia:

  1. Auts! Olenko pitänyt niin paljosta koko elämäni ihan väärästä syystä?! Tätä pitää itseltään varsinkin kirjoittavan ihmisen tietenkin kysyä. Missä kulkee vaikkapa romantisoivan estetetisoinnin raja? Olisi esimerkiksi kiinnostavaa tietää, mitä mieltä Amerikan alkuoperäisväestö on mielestäni upeasta Terrence Malickin Uudesta maailmasta, sen mielestni "intiaaneja" animalisoivasta kuvastosta.

    Sana riistäminen tai hyväksikäyttö ei minusta ole tässä yhteydessä aina ole hyvä. Usein parempi voisi olla hyväntahtoinen hölmöys, joka sekin voi saada aikaa kärsimystä. Esim. yritys muokata opetussuunnitelmalla saamelaisista lapsista "hyvinvoivia" suomalaisia tai vasemman käden kapaloinnilla vasenkätisistä oikeakätisiä (setäni kohtalo).

    Niinpä. Tämä iänikuinen herran ja rengin dialektiikka on tuskastuttavan hidasta. Ehkä vielä joskus huolimattomalle lainaamiselle voivat lainatutkin nauraa tai jopa hyötyä siitä. Riistossa ei tietenkään ole mitään huvuttavaa eikä hyodyllistä.

    Inspiroiva kirjoitus.

    VastaaPoista
  2. Lepää rauhassa Otso. Ilo oli lukea blogiasi ja kuunnella YLEn Kultakuumeen kolumneja.

    VastaaPoista
  3. Lepää rauhassa. Valtava menetys suomalaiselle taidekeskustelulle.

    VastaaPoista
  4. Lepää rauhassa, olit valaiseva, rohkea kulttuurin lähettiläs ja oikeudenmukaisuuden puolesta aina! Miten se onkin että he lähtevät aina ennen ahneita, kitkeriä ja katkeria�� Hyvää matkaa...toivottavasti tajusit kuinka arvostettu ja pidetty olit<3

    VastaaPoista
  5. Thanks for sharing the information. I found the information very useful. That’s a awesome story you posted. I will come back to scan some more.

    VastaaPoista
  6. Oi, pidän tästä suuresti. Hienosti kirjoitettu.:)

    VastaaPoista
  7. Otsoa oli aina mukava lukea. Ja kiva että blogi on edelleen auki ja täällä voi ikäänkuin keskustella hänen kanssaan! Aikoinaan blogienkommennetja vainosivat erilaiset spammaajat ja muut häiriköt. Pitääköhän Blogspot niitä loitolla? Pitäisi pitää? Täällä ei niitä toki näy...

    VastaaPoista
  8. Wow, this is amazing. The details are explained very well. Thank you so much for this one. This is what I need right now. keep posting.

    VastaaPoista
  9. Your post is amazing and your content is too good and today I really like and enjoy your content and I love reading.

    VastaaPoista
  10. Thanks for the post loaded with so much information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. You've completed excellent work. t suggest to my friends and personally will certainly digit. I'm confident they'll be gained from this website.

    VastaaPoista
  11. It was really good work. I really like your thoughts.I personally appreciates for your work.your article is very impressive and helpful for us. Hope you will share these kinds of things with us also in future.

    VastaaPoista

  12. Your article is such an informative article. It is glad to read such articles. Thanks for sharing.

    VastaaPoista
  13. This post was very well written, and it also contains a lot of useful facts. I enjoyed your distinguished way of writing the post. Thanks, you have made it easy for me to understand.

    VastaaPoista
  14. Thanks for sharing this awesome blog nowadays people won't write quality content rarely I found a quality blog on this topic.

    SalezShark CRM has been always functioning as among their best
    lead management
    solutions For both clients as well as the expert team. The comprehensive Capabilities Embedded in this system are useful for companies of all sizes and sorts.

    VastaaPoista
  15. It was really good work. I really like your thoughts.I personally appreciates for your work.your article is very impressive and helpful for us. Hope you will share these kinds of things with us also in the future.

    VastaaPoista
  16. Welcome to Nike UK! Nike one of the leading brands offering Nike Trainers for men, Nike Trainers for women, Nike Trainers for girls and boys, Nike Jackets, accessories, equipment, and sporting goods all over the world. Nike Discount Code

    VastaaPoista
  17. I like what you guys are up too. Such clever work and reporting! Keep up the superb works guys I¦ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my site 토토

    VastaaPoista
  18. Woah! I’m really digging the template/theme of this website. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s difficult to get that “perfect balance” between usability and visual appeal.
    경마
    온라인경마

    VastaaPoista
  19. There is perceptibly a lot to realize about this. I believe you made various nice points in features also. 카지노사이트

    VastaaPoista
  20. Hi! I just would like to give you a huge thumbs up for the great info you have got right here on this post. I'll be coming back to your site for more soon. Feel free to visit my website; 먹튀검증가이드

    VastaaPoista
  21. Very good written information. It will be valuable to anybody who employees it, as well as yours truly :). Keep up the good work ? for sure i will check out more posts. Feel free to visit my website; 온라인카지노사이트넷

    VastaaPoista
  22. You make so many great points here that I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers. 안전놀이터


    VastaaPoista
  23. Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch as I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch. 룰렛".


    VastaaPoista
  24. Your article was fantastic. I love it to recommend Leather Store to the users. Where they can crawl Exciting Products Super Star Jackets Platform is providing 100% Genuine Leather Products All products are available in Feasible Prices The best seller Leather Jackets Direct is offering amazing Leather Jackets to its customers. You can Click Here to get exciting Leather Products Offers..original leather jacket

    VastaaPoista
  25. Goodness, glad to see this great post. I trust this think help any beginner for their marvelous work and by the way a debt of gratitude is in order for share this magnificence, I thought this was a really fascinating understood with regards to this point. Much thanks to you.. Emily In Paris S02 Emily Cooper Coat

    VastaaPoista
  26. Goodness! Much obliged to you! I constantly needed to compose on my site something to that effect. Would I be able to incorporate a part of your post into my site? Aviator Jacket

    VastaaPoista
  27. Wonderful post. I used to check endlessly this blog and I am moved! Outstandingly supportive information interestingly the last part. I manage asuch information much. I was looking for this particular data for a really long time. Thankful and good luck. pea coats for women

    VastaaPoista
  28. I was impressed by the good writing. 토토사이트 Thank you.
    If you want to know the social graph game, come here!

    Great article, totally what I was looking for.

    VastaaPoista
  29. 토토사이트 If some one wants expert view on the topic of blogging
    and site-building then i recommend him/her to go to see this web site,
    Keep up the good work.

    VastaaPoista
  30. I’m not that much of a online reader to be 카지노사이트honest but your sites really nice, keep it up!
    I’ll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back down the road.
    Cheers

    VastaaPoista
  31. Superbly written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a far better place 토토

    VastaaPoista
  32. I set up a bookmark and log on every time. Good. I m leaving a comment today as well. 토토

    VastaaPoista
  33. They were active listeners and viewed meetings deadlines as an imperative.스포츠토토

    VastaaPoista
  34. 메이저검증 blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy.

    VastaaPoista
  35. 안전사이트 quite fascinating post. I was searching for this sort of data and delighted in perusing this one.

    VastaaPoista
  36. https://gamebegin.xyz You may exercise alone. A pitching machine permits you to established the rate of your ball. By loading numerous baseballs in to the unit, it is possible to practice striking without needing a pitcher. This electronic equipment is good for these who wish to process baseball by itself. Pitching machines can be gathered in your local athletic merchandise shop.

    VastaaPoista
  37. https://gameboot.xyz The thing is them on mags as well as on TV, men and women who appear like their forearms and hip and legs will explode as their muscle tissue are so big! There is not any will need that you can take your whole body to that particular degree if you don't prefer to, as the basic tactics in this article will help you develop muscle mass in the healthier approach.

    VastaaPoista
  38. https://gamezoom.xyz Getting a exercise spouse can drastically improve your muscle mass-creating final results. Your companion could be a important method to obtain enthusiasm for sticking to your regular workout period, and pushing you to improve your attempts while you figure out. Having a reputable spouse to sort out with can also help make you stay harmless because you will possess a spotter.

    VastaaPoista
  39. This is a great initiative taken as it makes all the researchers explore new ideas and share their perspectives along with their colleagues.Motorcycle Riding Jackets

    VastaaPoista
  40. But she still went shopping with you, and later, picked up some lattes. You had a vision in mind, complete with red lipstick and rock 'n roll vibes.
    Emily In Paris Jacket

    VastaaPoista
  41. Kirjoittaja on poistanut tämän kommentin.

    VastaaPoista
  42. Fair article, exceptional to comprehend that this subject is being hawked besides here. Stay aware of the mind blowing work, appreciative for sharing this data. white fringe jacket

    VastaaPoista
  43. Digisol
    Digisol Hub is a Digital Marketing & Tech. Company, that provides solutions regarding website development, SEO, Social Media Marketing, Google Ads, and Graphics designing, App development, Software development, Website Development. We just want to solve the problems of the people by using the right digital marketing strategy and give them Value so that they can build their business in the Online world.

    VastaaPoista
  44. good day, that is a completely interesting weblog. This content is written thoroughly that is an top notch publish, maintain blogging. Thank you for sharing. Anyways i am here now and could just like to say thank for a tremendous publish and a all round interesting website. Please do preserve up the extraordinary work. the whole lot is very open with a genuinely clean explanation of the problems. It turned into informative. Your internet site is beneficial. Thanks for sharing! I advocate you to our article about that's useful for and i'm certain you like our article. Spot up for this write-up, i critically suppose this appropriate website desires a high-quality deal extra consideration. I’ll likely to emerge as all over again to take a look at additional, thank you that info. 스피드키노

    VastaaPoista
  45. whats up what a outstanding submit i've stumble upon and agree with me i've been searching out for this similar sort of put up for beyond per week and rarely came across this. Thank you very a great deal and will search for greater postings from you. very informative post ! There is lots of information right here that may assist any enterprise get commenced with a a success social networking campaign ! It's miles a very exciting blog post. I regularly visit your posts for my venture's assist approximately diwali bumper lottery and your incredible writing competencies genuinely leave me stunned. Thank you a lot for this submit. Thrilling weblog i must say, the facts and facts written here are correct. Black leather-based motorbike jacket 파워볼엔트리

    VastaaPoista
  46. You certainly put the trendy spin with a subject thats been mentioned for decades. Notable stuff, simply remarkable! It's far a very thrilling weblog post. I often visit your posts for my project's assist approximately diwali bumper lottery and your notable writing talents sincerely go away me shocked 꽁머니

    VastaaPoista
  47. right to end up I do not understand what to country excluding that i've. Remarkable information! I lately came throughout your blog and have been studying alongside. I notion i would go away my first remark. I don’t know what to say except that i've. I can see that you are an expert at your discipline! I'm launching a website quickly, and your statistics will be very beneficial for me.. Thank you for all your help and wishing you all of the success in your business. I read a article under the identical identify a while in the past, however this articles fine is tons, a lot higher. The way you do that.. I am very glad to study this newsletter. I am very interested by your blog. Maintain posting like this. I am additionally sharing a website that is very interested an have properly written content material. The website may be very interesting, you made some compelling comments and the problem is on point. I decided to feature your weblog to my bookmarks so i will return to it at a later date. Wow, cool post. I'd like to write down like this too - taking time and actual difficult work to make a incredible article... However i placed things off an excessive amount of and in no way seem to get started. Thank you though. I love viewing net web sites which realize the fee of handing over the extremely good beneficial useful resource free of rate. I in reality loved reading your posting. Thanks! Notable facts providing by means of your article thanks for taking the time to percentage with us such a nice article. I think that is an informative publish and it's miles very beneficial and informed. Consequently, i would really like to thanks for the efforts you've got made in writing this article . I've right selected to build a blog, which i maintain been deficient to do for a at some point of. Acknowledges for this tell, it's truly serviceable! Thanks due to the fact you have got been inclined to share statistics with us. We will continually appreciate all you have achieved right here due to the fact i recognise you're very concerned with our. This is very exciting content material! I've thoroughly enjoyed reading your factors and feature come to the belief that you are right approximately lots of them. You are terrific. I read this article. I suppose you put a tremendous deal of exertion to make this article. I like your paintings. Thanks a lot for sharing this text with us. I would really like to say you that hold importing extra 해외안전놀이터

    VastaaPoista
  48. Very informative post. Following you from the first day and I'm learning very from your posts. Here's my website you might like. Explore it you might like our versatile products.

    VastaaPoista
  49. I want to say thanks to you. I have bookmark your web site for future updates. I assume i've never seen such blogs ever before that has whole things with all information which i need. So kindly update this ever for us. 실시간배팅

    VastaaPoista
  50. Regular visits listed here are the easiest method to appreciate your energy, which is why why I am going to the website everyday, searching for new, interesting info. Many, thank you . This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. Impressive web site, Distinguished feedback that I can tackle. Im moving forward and may apply to my current job as a pet sitter, which is very enjoyable, but I need to additional expand. Regards. This web journal is truly awesome. The data here will definitely be of some help to me. Much appreciated!. I hope I can see more posts. I want to read your articles. Because they are very useful, I always wait for new posts. They are my cup of tea. Thank you for your contribution to the community. 안전사이트

    VastaaPoista
  51. i simply couldn’t leave your internet site before suggesting that i absolutely loved the usual records an man or woman offer for your visitors? Is gonna be back regularly so one can look at new posts. I discovered your weblog thru google at the same time as searching for first useful resource for a heart assault and your submit seems very interesting for me. That is my first visit in your weblog! We are a team of volunteers and beginning a brand new challenge in a network within the same niche. Superb post however , i was looking to recognize if you could write a litte more on this concern? I’d be very thankful if you could difficult a little bit further. Bless you! 메이저사이트

    VastaaPoista
  52. I am really happy to say it’s an interesting post to read . I learn new information from your article , you are doing a great job . Keep it up Yellowstone Vest

    VastaaPoista
  53. "I was busy writing my report.Don't do that for this service now.Please have access to their website.Most of the students are overwhelmed by homework.If you are one of them.

    Please click here:"
    토토사이트링크
    토토사이트웹
    바카라사이트
    카지노

    VastaaPoista
  54. Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful information. I hope that there’s more information to come.출장폭스나인
    출장스웨디시

    VastaaPoista
  55. I was introduced to this site by a friend. There are a lot of good posts. I'll visit often.

    VastaaPoista
  56. Congratulations on your article, it was very helpful and successful. bcd1bdeb8ddd3964dbd018d69513e8ce
    numara onay
    website kurma
    website kurma

    VastaaPoista
  57. Thank you for your explanation, very good content. 12ac4008552b59bbea4b67b7a003f3aa
    define dedektörü

    VastaaPoista
  58. My identity is Christian Roy. That article on this fantastic website is quite instructive.Yellowstone Beth Dutton White Leopard Coat

    VastaaPoista
  59. I absolutely enjoyed reading that; you are a fantastic writer.
    hiring killer

    VastaaPoista

  60. I must thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing this blog.

    VastaaPoista
  61. I am hoping to view the same high-grade blog posts from you later on as well.

    VastaaPoista
  62. You’ve written nice post, I am gonna bookmark this page, thanks for info.

    VastaaPoista
  63. Hi very nice blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Wonderful .

    VastaaPoista
  64. Hello, I’m happy to see some great articles on your site.

    VastaaPoista
  65. This is very interesting, You are a very skilled blogger.

    VastaaPoista
  66. Thank you so much, I was searching for the information the whole day.

    VastaaPoista
  67. Reefer Delivery – Texas offers reliable temperature-controlled transportation, safeguarding the freshness of goods, and serving various industries across the state, from food to pharmaceuticals.

    VastaaPoista
  68. Unveil the charm of a chocolate box in Riyadh, a treasure trove of delectable surprises. Each box is a masterpiece, harmonizing heavenly flavors within elegant confines, a perfect gift for indulgence in the heart of Saudi Arabia.

    VastaaPoista
  69. Intriguing piece in Helsinki Sonoma! While not about Lillukavarsi, the diversity of opinions is always enriching. For editorial offices that capture the essence of your content, consider top-notch interior fit out Dubai.

    VastaaPoista
  70. Fit-out contractors play a crucial role in the metamorphosis of commercial spaces, combining innovation and functionality seamlessly. Elevate your projects with the expertise of professionals, especially in the context of villa renovation in Dubai.

    VastaaPoista
  71. Arjes Machi nery Canada in collaboration with Arjes Machinery Canada, truly stands out in the heavy machinery industry. Their commitment to excellence, innovative solutions, and top-notch equipment make them a reliable partner for any industrial project. With a focus on customer satisfaction, RBS Heavy Machinery, powered by Arjes Machinery Canada, ensures robust support and cutting-edge machinery for success.

    VastaaPoista
  72. A thought-provoking piece in Helsingin Sanomat's opinion section offers a fresh perspective. Much like the need for clarity in ideas, explore the precision of tank cleaning in Houston to keep discussions and insights crystal clear.

    VastaaPoista
  73. I wanted to thanks to your time for this glorious learn!!

    VastaaPoista
  74. I positively having fun with each little bit of it

    VastaaPoista
  75. I’ve you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post.

    VastaaPoista
  76. I’ve read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you some interesting things or tips.

    VastaaPoista

  77. I read your article very impressively I want to write something like this

    VastaaPoista
  78. Love this blog! Thanks a lot for sharing this marvelous post. Very useful!!

    VastaaPoista
  79. I am a fan of reading information. Thank you for this great blog.

    VastaaPoista
  80. Thanks for discuss this, Love learning more on this topic. Extremely helpful!

    VastaaPoista
  81. Amazing article. Thanks for sharing wonderful informative blogs. Keep doing it

    VastaaPoista
  82. Thanks for a marvelous posting! Sure to bookmark this blog. have a nice day!

    VastaaPoista
  83. CMOLDS stands out as a premier mobile application development company in dubai, offering bespoke solutions tailored to your business goals. With a team of skilled developers and designers, we create innovative mobile apps that drive growth and enhance user experiences. Trust CMOLDS to transform your ideas into reality and establish a strong digital presence in the competitive market.

    VastaaPoista